Theme 3: The real progress happens after the short-term workaround
Confronted with real barriers, staff often just work harder. They put in longer hours, and they make creative band-aids, custom processes, and local fixes to help learners navigate complex systems. These approaches reflect the dedication that college staff have to their students, and while their solutions are often effective in the short term or with a handful of students, they are not always scalable or sustainable. Individual champions are important, but the most important goal is redesigning the adult learner journey so that the workarounds are no longer needed.
We are currently seeing this dynamic of patchwork solutions play out in how colleges use technology, including AI. Colleges recognize the value of technology and AI for streamlining re-engagement, onboarding, advising, and access to information. They are especially excited about the ways that technology can free staff to do the high-value work that only people can do. The grantees provided multiple examples of creative, homegrown technological tools that reduce administrative and learner burdens—for example, tools that analyze student transcripts to identify opportunities to earn credit for prior learning. In the absence of an institutional redesign, these tools are necessary, but currently, the result is a patchwork of custom-built solutions rather than a well-designed system. AQL Labs, which joined a peer-learning session in July, challenged grantees to think differently about how and when to use AI, noting that when institutions redesign strategically around AI, rather than simply layering AI onto outdated systems, they may actually need AI less often.
Staff workarounds frequently signal to institutional leaders where redesign is most needed, so the next step is to use these patches as a starting point. After examining the complex situations that staff are trying to mitigate, leaders can design new processes that create the learning experiences that colleges want for all students.