The Administration’s Skinny Budget Has Outsized Negative Impacts for Americans
Although we don’t know the full details of the President’s proposed budget, beyond that provided in the recently revealed “skinny budget,” we at Jobs for the Future (JFF) are very concerned that dramatic cuts to critical programs such as workforce development and student aid and supports—that are designed to prepare America’s current and future workforce—are counterproductive, particularly at a time when the skills of American workers are essential to U.S. and individual economic prosperity.
While we are encouraged by the Administration’s support for apprenticeship, cuts to other workforce development programs would have a significant negative impact on Americans looking to gain the skills they need to secure family-supporting careers. We look forward to continuing to work with the Administration and Congress to ensure that a balanced approach to federal funding is reached—but that cannot be achieved solely through funding reductions from domestic discretionary programs that have already been cut significantly over the years.
One of the many federal programs the President’s proposed budget would cut is the Corporation for National and Community Service (CNCS), which funds AmeriCorps programs including VISTA, NCCC, and State and National. We are disheartened to see something as essential as public service identified as a target for cuts. These programs play a critical role in cultivating the next generation of people committed to careers that make our society stronger. They help make careers in public service both attractive and accessible to people of all backgrounds. In addition, when alumni of public service programs go on to work in nonprofits or in government, they do so with firsthand knowledge of the communities that programs and policies aim to benefit (stories of some of JFF’s staff alumni follow).
Cutting funding for national service means narrowing the talent pipeline for organizations addressing pressing issues like economic mobility and educational opportunity. As the Center for American Progress and Voices for Service (among others) have rightly pointed out, eliminating the CNCS would have negative consequences for the numerous communities and individuals across the country that are served by programs funded through CNCS, and would be a devastating blow to education reform. These programs have longstanding bipartisan support and a clear return on investment—2:1 returns in terms of tax revenues and decreased spending on other government programs.
For many of us at Jobs for the Future, programs like AmeriCorps, VISTA, and NCCC were the first step on our own career pathways that ultimately led us to JFF. With this program potentially on the chopping block, we want to highlight how these national service programs shaped our own career choices, and as a hint of how greater investment in public service could lead to more citizens dedicated to working to make our country the best it can be, and keeping communities strong for all of their citizens.
Read about our experiences:
Rachel McDonnell, JFF Associate Director, AmeriCorps
Joe Deegan, JFF Program Manager, AmeriCorps VISTA
Allysha Roth, JFF Program Manager, Kiwanis Clubs & AmericCorps
Jessica Toglia, JFF Program Associate, AmeriCorps VISTA
Tyler Nakatsu, JFF Communications Manager, AmeriCorps VISTA
Daniel West, JFF Program Manager, McNair Scholar
Rachel McDonnell: Fostering Social Change Careers
As an AmeriCorps alum, I’ve seen firsthand the impact that these programs have on communities. In my AmeriCorps program, we provided afterschool enrichment in underserved areas, painted murals on community playgrounds, used art as a storytelling tool with recent immigrants, and taught music classes for the elderly. Through AmeriCorps, I met immigrants who had left behind families and careers so that their children would have greater opportunities, creative children who worried about violence in their neighborhoods, and teenagers whose high school internships had helped shape their career goals. My AmeriCorps experience led me to study education policy, which in turn led me to JFF. In particular, my experiences working with underserved communities illustrated the connections between education, workforce development, economic development, and social policy—issues that I continue to address on a larger scale through my work at JFF.
One of the powerful aspects of programs like AmeriCorps is that they can and do attract a wide variety of people into public service. My own program included volunteers of all ages, all education levels, all races and ethnicities, and all income levels. To use JFF terms, they provide a valuable on-ramp to mission-driven careers. Rather than cutting funding for CNCS, I’d love to see the U.S. expand these programs and provide more opportunities to engage the next generation of people dedicated to social change.
Joe Deegan: Restoring Faith in Communities
Through my work with AmeriCorps VISTA, I helped higher education institutions build high-quality partnerships with local nonprofits. The projects I created not only enhanced learning for undergraduate students, but helped these universities produce more social goods to justify their tax-exempt status. My peers and I regularly generated in-kind value worth multiple times the small investment in our AmeriCorps stipends.
The interpersonal benefits of AmeriCorps programs are even more important. I witnessed how highly visible programs like VISTA, CityYear, and others restored the faith of New Orleanians in their government after the failures of Katrina. Energetic and skilled AmeriCorps volunteers believed in that city. Many of them stayed, putting down roots and founding nonprofit agencies of their own.
As a VISTA volunteer, I learned about the struggles of low-income Americans firsthand. Many of them were my colleagues and friends. I lived on a small stipend myself, sometimes facing difficult decisions about where my next dollars would go. My own path was changed by my service as a VISTA volunteer. It is no coincidence that I went on to earn an MPA and work for an organization like JFF that helps higher education partners increase their social impact. VISTA and its peer programs under CNCS create a talent pipeline for public service by exposing young people and emerging professionals to the institutions that the most vulnerable Americans rely on, and putting them to work right away to make those institutions better.
Allysha Roth: Finding Service as a Career
When I applied for AmeriCorps, I had been in Kiwanis clubs for five years between high school and college. I totally lived, and still try to live, the motto of Kiwanis "Live to serve. Love to serve." But, I didn’t really think of community service as being a career track. It was isolated to volunteering and fundraising. When I was finishing my bachelor's degree in psychology, I knew I wanted to go to graduate school, but really wasn't sure for exactly what. And it was important to me that I got that right, because I knew from experience how painful it is—a loss of precious time, money, and energy—to go down a path and realize it's not the one you really want to be on. I asked myself what I really loved doing and the answer was service. So I applied for AmeriCorps.
I spent the next two years of my life immersed in the field of affordable housing, learning how to build houses from the ground up and communicate how affordable homeownership can be a steppingstone toward financial stability and economic opportunity. I realized that I could do much, much more than volunteer my time and money. It could be my life's work. My AmeriCorps experience continues to illuminate my personal path to this day. I'm really grateful that I had the opportunity to truly "live to serve".
Jessica Toglia: Gaining a New Perspective
My AmeriCorps VISTA service experience was invaluable and has provided me knowledge that I bring to my JFF work. I was a part of the Ohio Campus Compact, a network of colleges and universities throughout the state that hosted VISTA volunteers working on creating educational opportunities. My responsibilities included increasing community partnerships and student volunteerism. Specifically, I was located at a regional campus, Miami University-Hamilton, in the Center for Civic Engagement. Having attended the main campus, Miami University in Oxford, Ohio, which touts itself as a “Public Ivy” for grad school, moving to the regional campus was an eye-opener. It was here that my definition of “college student” broadened to include nontraditional students and particularly those who faced significant barriers to achieving their education. Thus, AmeriCorps VISTA definitely influenced my career path in terms of social justice and education. It also gave me firsthand knowledge of the issues that JFF works on and that I care about so deeply.
Tyler Nakatsu: It’s Everyone’s Responsibility
Alex sat across from me in a windowless conference room at the Hilton in Crystal City, Virginia. I had rearranged the furniture, unplugged the mini-fridge, and prepped my popup set for us to film. Alex had lived in public housing with his grandmother in Denver. When his grandma could no longer travel to renew their SNAP benefits he turned to what was available, got into trouble, and left school. I filmed Alex for three days, in meetings on the Hill, talking late into the night about his journey to postsecondary education as a young low-income “dropout” man of color.
Just a few months prior, I had traded in my marketing job in Seattle for a year as an AmeriCorps VISTA with YouthBuild USA. I graduated from college at the height of the recession. Finding a job was difficult, but figuring out what drove me was oddly crushing. This was when I discovered that telling my unique story was what enabled me to connect the vision of my future self with where I was stuck.
Now that vision is to work with leaders who are addressing issues related career advancement like I experienced, but also the systemic problems of educational access and economic growth that Alex faced. However, my national service story shouldn't be about how much service has changed the trajectory of my life. This can lead to framing service as a savior practice. While it's true that I'm privileged to the extent that I was able to dedicate myself to national service, I didn't sign up because of me. I signed up because too many communities have been subject to systemic racism, oppression, and disenfranchisement that has led to intergenerational poverty that everyone has a responsibility to work both within and outside of systems of power to undo and improve.
I still text with Alex. He sends me snapchat messages of his son as he says goodbye to them on their way to school. I respond usually with affirmations and support, as I work at my desk thankful that I had shared moments of service with him.
Daniel West: Other Programs Have Unexpected Consequences
The McNair Scholars program is a federal TRIO program that provides overachieving students from disadvantaged backgrounds an opportunity to gain research experience during the summer semester, paving the way for college access. McNair removes the financial barriers associated with being an undergraduate research assistant. While most labs will take on undergraduate students as lab assistants, they often don’t have the budgets to pay these students. Understanding that research experience is vital to a graduate school application, most students would jump at the opportunity to volunteer in a federally funded research lab. However, extended unpaid work assignments aren’t a reality for low-income students.
An unpaid summer experience was definitely not an option for me. The TRIO programs, especially McNair, hold a special significance to me. The Morehouse College McNair Scholars Program shepherded my transition in to grad school from inception through acceptance. Through the program I was able to attend out-of-state graduate school tours in addition to targeted graduate school recruitment events as a means of connecting with key admissions personnel. Additionally, I received professional assistance with preparing applications, free GRE prep, vouchers for discounted testing as well as application fee waivers. If it were not for the financial assistance offered by the McNair program, through the TRIO grant, I would have had to postpone or even forego my graduate education plans. Thanks to McNair, I am proud to say that I am an award-winning educational researcher with a graduate degree from an Ivy League university; possibilities I had never considered as a low-income kid from DC. As a McNair scholar I was introduced to a whole new world of opportunity, accelerating my pathway to graduate education and further; securing a great job post-graduation. Millions of low- to middle- income students like myself certainly see the value of programs like these, and need them to work toward our dreams.
See comments from our President and CEO Maria Flynn in the news:
- Trump’s Job Training Cuts Cloud Labor Hearing by Bloomberg BNA
- Trump Budget Targets Programs That Help People Get Jobs by Reveal News
- What Trump’s Budget Outline Would Mean for Higher Ed by The Chronicle of Higher Education